The Roger Smith Hotel

The hotel stay was just ok. The beds are not comfortable. No ice machine on the floor. Called downstairs didn’t get the ice until about an hour later, I was getting ready to go to sleep. They forgot. Other than that the hotel is very clean. It was fine for a one night stay.

We stayed here for the second time this year, great location close to lots of shopping, great restaurants and sight seeing. 20 minutes from LaGuardia airport. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable and pricing is very fair for new New York. Rooms overall comfortable and clean.

Ok room in very tired hotel. Room was big by NY standards but just needs a big overhaul. Snacks and coffee provided which was a pleasant surprise.

Hotel is a mixed bag. Older property, condition wise, but more spacious rooms than the new hotels offer especially nice if yoi have to be there a few days or need to do work from yoiur room. room had upholstered love seat and chair which were comfortable. Hallways were dark, room has bumps and bruises appearance wise, but everything works fine and the room is comfortable. Staff is nice and location is wonderful, 4 blocks to subway and 6 blocks to grand Central. nice restaurants close by. If all was upgraded to new standards, wouod cost $100 more a night, so, keep that in mind. Room was quiet relative to other hotel guests and activities but noise came from outside at night for dumpster emptying activities and EMT sirens, etc. All in all, enjoyable stay.

Really comfortable but not perfect. Kinda reminds me of grandma's. Warm, welcoming, but a little worn and dated. But the are some really great things. The front desk staff is awesome. The guest lounge is homey, quiet and well stocked with yogart and granola. Biggest issue was street noise. Nothing seriously wrong and will stay here again. Hopefully higher and not facing Lexington.